- Jessie Mueller/Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble - What Baking Can Do
- Waitress Original Broadway Company - Opening Up (Finale)
- The Waitress Band - Pomatter Pie
- Christopher Fitzgerald/Kimiko Glenn - Never Ever Getting Rid of Me
- Lana Del Rey - White Dress
- Jessie Mueller - She Used to Be Mine
- Waitress - Rubio's Lament
- Waitress - We Own You
- Hop Along - Waitress
- Jessie Mueller/Keala Settle - A Soft Place to Land
- Dakin Matthews/Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble - Take It from an Old Man
- Jessie Mueller/Drew Gehling - Bad Idea
- Keala Settle - I Didn't Plan It
- Drew Gehling/Jessie Mueller - You Matter to Me
- Kimiko Glenn/Jessie Mueller - When He Sees Me
- Nick Cordero/Jessie Mueller - You Will Still Be Mine
- Keala Settle/Kimiko Glenn - The Negative
- Drew Gehling/Jessie Mueller - It Only Takes a Taste
- Jessie Mueller/Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble - What's Inside
- Jessie Mueller/Keala Settle - Everything Changes